Skip to content
Back$3,795,0005 bd5 ba4,180 sqft

$3,795,000For sale

5917 Overlake Ave

San Diego, CA 92120 · MLS# 260019259SD

Listing courtesy of Compass
  • 5Beds
  • 5Baths
  • 4,180Sq Ft
  • 1964Year Built

About This Home

Perched above the tranquil waters of Lake Murray, this newly reimagined home blends new construction with heavily renovated living spaces, sweeping views that stretch from the shimmering lake to the surrounding mountains, and glimpses of the Pacific Ocean and Coronado Bridge. Offering approximately 4,180 SF, 5 bedrooms, 4.5 bathrooms, and a 2-car garage, the home features a versatile floor plan with two primary suites; a main level suite ideal for multigenerational living or guests, and a private upstairs retreat opening to a wraparound balcony where lake and mountain views and vivid sunrises become part of daily life. Disappearing walls of glass flood in natural light and extend the living spaces outdoors to a lush lawn, sunken fire lounge, and beautifully landscaped grounds for entertaining from sunrise through twilight. The chef’s kitchen centers on a backlit Cristallo quartzite waterfall island, paired with Taj Mahal quartzite, custom cabinetry, and premium appliances, flowing effortlessly into open living and dining spaces. The primary bath serves as a private spa with a freestanding soaking tub framed by lake and mountain views, floating stone vanities, and warm, organic textures throughout, complemented by wide plank hardwood floors and bespoke lighting. One of only 16 residences along this coveted hillside, the home offers direct access to Lake Murray’s trails and natural beauty, top-rated schools including Hearst Elementary and Patrick Henry HS, no HOA, and easy access to shopping, dining, and major freeways. A rare opportunity in highly sought after Del Cerro.

Continue readingShow less

Want to see this home in person?

Request a private tour, ask a quick question, or call now before another buyer gets serious about 5917 Overlake Ave.

Property at a Glance: 5917 Overlake Ave

This single family residence property at 5917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, CA 92120 is for sale at $3,795,000. The home has 5 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms and 4,180 square feet of living space. It was built in 1964 and sits on a lot of 0.25 acres. That comes to about $908 per square foot. Reach out to set up a showing or ask for more details about this home.

Snapshot

Status
For sale
Price
$3,795,000
Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
5
Full Baths
4
Half Baths
1
Property Type
Single Family Residence
Year Built
1964
Square Feet
4,180
Lot Size
0.25 acres
Days on Market
46
MLS #
260019259SD
Price per Sq Ft
$908
County
San Diego
Subdivision
Del Cerro

Need a quick answer before the details?

Call now about 5917 Overlake Ave and ask about showings, availability, or offer timing.

Call 858-518-2875

Property Details

Building
Property Type: Single Family Residence
Year Built: 1964
Stories: 2
Architectural Style: Contemporary, Modern
Land
Lot Size: 0.25 acres
View: Mountain(s), Panoramic, River
Money
County: San Diego
Rooms
Heating: Forced Air, Natural Gas
Cooling: Central Air
Appliances: Built-In Range, Counter Top, Dishwasher, Electric Cooktop, Freezer, Disposal, Gas Water Heater, Microwave, Refrigerator
Interior: Walk-In Closet(s)
Fireplace: Living Room
Laundry: Electric Dryer Hookup, Gas Dryer Hookup, Laundry Room
Structures
Garage Spaces: 2
Parking: Driveway
Pool: None
Construction: Stucco
Roof: Shingle
Fencing: Vinyl
Systems
Water Source: Public

Del Cerro in San Diego, CA

5917 Overlake Ave is in the Del Cerro neighborhood of San Diego, CA. Ask Brad & Karen Mattonen about other homes for sale in Del Cerro and what nearby homes have sold for.

Location

5917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, CA 92120 Open in Google Maps

Mortgage Calculator

Estimated Monthly Payment$19,190
$3,036,000Loan Amount
$759,000Down Payment
$3,872,251Total Interest

Principal and interest only. Taxes, insurance and HOA dues are extra.

Brad & Karen Mattonen Can Answer Your Questions About This Home

Why Work With Brad & Karen Mattonen?

Buying a home in San Diego, CA goes better with a local agent on your side. Brad & Karen Mattonen can set up private showings, pull the latest numbers for the area, and guide you through the offer and the closing. Call 858-518-2875 to get started. Whether 5917 Overlake Ave is the one or you would like to see other homes nearby, reach out any time.

Local facts

Facts and context beyond the MLS description

What the numbers say about 5917 Overlake Ave and the San Diego area around it.

Current market context

How this home compares in San Diego

  • $908This home per sq ft
  • $683Median per sq ft
  • 229Homes for sale like it
  • 1Average days on market

At $908 per square foot, 5917 Overlake Ave is priced about 33% above the $683 median for 5 or more bedroom homes for sale in San Diego now.

Nearby sold homes

Recent sold homes near this property

Homes that sold within 1.25 miles of 5917 Overlake Ave in the last 6 months, at a median price of $2,025,000.

AddressSoldHomeSold priceDistance
6666 NormanMay 4, 20264 bd · 2 ba · 2,396 sqft$2,285,0000.2 mi
6117 MadraJun 3, 20264 bd · 3 ba · 2,632 sqft$2,415,0000.3 mi
6641 Murray Park DriveMay 26, 20265 bd · 3 ba · 2,721 sqft$2,000,0000.3 mi
5915 MadraAug 7, 20264 bd · 4 ba · 2,667 sqft$2,250,0000.3 mi
6315 Ridge ManorJul 2, 20263 bd · 2 ba · 2,748 sqft$2,050,0000.3 mi
6688 Murray Park DriveMay 26, 20264 bd · 3 ba · 2,402 sqft$1,354,0000.4 mi
6727 Cavite Ct.Aug 4, 20263 bd · 4 ba · 3,403 sqft$1,900,0000.4 mi
5759 CalvinMay 21, 20263 bd · 2 ba · 1,631 sqft$1,275,7500.5 mi

Every home is different. Ask for a full price review before you make an offer.

Listing timeline

Price and status history

DateEventPrice
Oct 15, 2026Active$3,795,000

Similar Homes Nearby

Homes for sale in San Diego close to this home's price.

See more homes for sale

Want to see this home?

Call Today: 858-518-2875

Interested in 5917 Overlake Ave?

Get in touch with Brad & Karen Mattonen to learn more about this property or schedule a private showing.

Or call 858-518-2875
5917 Overlake Ave, San Diego5917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 25917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 35917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 45917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 55917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 65917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 75917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 85917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 95917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 105917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 115917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 125917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 135917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 145917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 155917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 165917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 175917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 185917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 195917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 205917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 215917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 225917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 235917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 245917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 255917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 265917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 275917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 285917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 295917 Overlake Ave, San Diego, photo 30
Log inRegister